About 3 years ago, we posted a few steps to take when considering an elevator modernization. The following is a repost with changes and updates:
For condominium boards, an elevator modernization is one of the most expensive and complicated processes made during their time on the board or as decision makers. You could need to modernize due to obsolescence, age or to ensure reliability. How do you know what to do?
Step 1 – Talk to your elevator service provider about the current status of the elevator and where it is in its life cycle. A quick conversation should help focus the discussion on what the future may hold. Get general pricing and information on the recommended general scope, including work performed by other professionals (also called “work by others”).
Step 2 - Aside from obsolescence, age and reliability, also consider the implications of a change to the elevator safety code. The State of Illinois, with the exception of the City of Chicago, is expected to adopt a modified version of the ASME A17.1 2025 code. This affects:
- New construction and modernizations will require additional safety features. If initial converstions and proposals referenced the current 2019 code, they will need to be altered to include items required in the 2025 version.
- Existing elevators will need to meet a retroactive safety requirement (called door lock monitoring) once the 2025 code is adopted. On the surface this may appear to have nothing to do with a modernization, but depending on the extent to which the elevator needs to be retrofit a mod may be the better option. Especially if the elevator already has obsolete components or is having reliability issues. In this instance, instead of considering an upgrade which only addresses door lock montitoring, the building may wish to spend a little more to fix both issues at once.
Step 3 – When it is time to get formal proposals, have a general understanding of them and the items that are replaced as well as those being retained. Most of the time, the entire elevator does not need to be gutted and this can be a cost savings. Additionally have a general understanding, of the proposals by other trades associated with electrical work, fire panel work, etc as they may need to be completed in conjunction with the elevator's modernization. THERE SHOULD BE NO CHARGE FOR THE INITIAL SURVEY OR QUOTATION
Step 4 – Go beyond the formal proposals and meet with the companies that are bidding the work. Talk to them, get their take on your project, what should be completed, and what they can offer. Make sure they answer your calls and/or emails when you have questions. If you’re building is very proactive with communication and likes to ask questions on Saturday, and expects answers on Saturday, make sure those companies are available. Some sales people/companies are 9am-5pm M-F, some sales people/companies are 24/7 with their communication. Get a feeling for what companies fit your building’s needs for communication. A modernization is a long-term project so you want your expectations understood early on.
Step 5 – Review the differences in the proposals, highlight the areas you do not understand, take notes, and ask questions. Communicate with the other companies and ask questions about why their proposal may look different, especially if they are an outlier. Unfortunately all of your modernization proposals may include different items and have different language which affects pricing. We recommend that if there is someone you feel comfortable with and are leaning towards, work with that person to assist you in understanding those differences. We spend a lot of time walking building owners/managers through differences in proposals; we want a building owner to feel comfortable and understand what we are proposing and why.
Step 6 – Make a decision based on your understanding of future costs of elevator modernization, costs of “work by others”, lead times, cylinder hole potentials, time the elevator will be out of service, what storage requirements your contractor may have while on site and other items that may pop up during the project. We would like to talk about them now versus when we go onsite.
Apples to apples – This is a challenge when reviewing contracts. We have seen some companies become more competitive when quoting, but they leave work out. If there is a reason not to change a part, that is ok, but you should understand and be aware of what is included in company A versus company B & C.
If your elevator is 50 years old and company A & B are including all part replacements for car and hatch door equipment and company C is not, company C’s price will look better, but they also are doing a different scope. Above you have two different contracts, one includes door operators and door work [clutch, door rollers, interlock assemblies, door contacts, gibs], one only includes a door operator. Make sure you know what you are getting and that you are OK not getting what you are not getting.
If you have any questions or would like additional information feel free to contact me at CraigZ@colleyelevator.com or 630-766-7230 ext. 107.
Also check us out on Instagram @Colleyelevator see what we have been up to.






































